Totapuri, the supposed lineage, the first "Master"
  Archive
Posted by:
A ®

03/13/2006, 21:49:52
Author Profile


Alert Forum Admin





A few years ago I wrote a post where I stated
"... Do you know that Maharaji has contradicted his own father as to who was Totapuri's successor? Try doing some research on Totapuri, who is supposedly M's great-great-great-grand-guru. Here's a link: The God Who is a Person. ..."

I don't remember what I read that led me to conclude that he contradicted his father.

I found a new link to The God Who is a Person

"For instance, Totapuri, one of Ramakrishna's teachers, criticized him for worshipping Krishna with dancing, chanting, and clapping hands. Totapuri sarcastically asked ([123],166-7) if Ramakrishna was clapping bread dough between his hands. Totapuri was a strict monist. He regarded Gods who are Persons as mythological, that is, as having less real existence than you or I."

A logical problem with this "you need a Master" concept:

Who did the first "Master" receive "Knowledge" from?





Modified by A at Mon, Mar 13, 2006, 21:51:27

Previous Recommend Current page Next

Replies to this message

Re: Totapuri, the supposed lineage, the first "Master"
Re: Totapuri, the supposed lineage, the first "Master" -- A Top of thread Archive
Posted by:
Andries ®

03/14/2006, 01:35:57
Author Profile


Alert Forum Admin




That is a different Totapuri. Those Indian titles and religious names lead to a lot of confusion.

Andries







Previous Recommend Current page Next
Please choose whether you are 'A' or 'G'
Re: Totapuri, the supposed lineage, the first "Master" -- A Top of thread Archive
Posted by:
JHB-Admin ®

03/14/2006, 03:03:46
Author Profile


Alert Forum Admin




You said you wanted to revert to your historic id of 'G' so you re-registered, but you continue to use 'A'.  Please choose one so I can delete the other.

Thanks,

John.






Previous Recommend Current page Next
I'll go with 'G', you can delete 'A'. Thanks.
Re: Please choose whether you are 'A' or 'G' -- JHB-Admin Top of thread Archive
Posted by:
G ®

03/14/2006, 18:33:24
Author Profile


Alert Forum Admin










Previous Recommend Current page Next
I'll go with 'G', you can delete 'A'.
Re: Please choose whether you are 'A' or 'G' -- JHB-Admin Top of thread Archive
Posted by:
G ®

03/14/2006, 18:35:07
Author Profile


Alert Forum Admin




I had a little trouble deciding because someone else posted as 'G.' in 2004, but I think 'G' is preferable.

Thanks.







Previous Recommend Current page Next
Don't you know anything?
Re: Totapuri, the supposed lineage, the first "Master" -- A Top of thread Archive
Posted by:
lesley ®

03/14/2006, 12:41:08
Author Profile


Alert Forum Admin




God of course.

Ah it was so much easier back in the days when the earth was only 5000 years old and man was made in God's image.







Previous Recommend Current page Next